Gruppo di discussione in Scienze Cognitive
presentazione:introduction persone:people discussione:working papers strumenti:community tools info:about us

  annotitoloautore
2003Embodied and Distributed Aspects of Abductive Diagnostic ReasoningAlberto Gatti
  informazioni Proceedings of EuroCogSci03: The European Cognitive Science Con
  keywordsTheoretical Abduction; Manipulative Abduction; Epistemic Actions; Distributed Cognition
  abstract 
In this paper we introduce diagnostic reasoning through a case study which demonstrates the presence of a mixture of theoretical and extra-theoretical thinking activities. The concept of ’theoretical’ abduction is the most suitable one for modeling the process of discovery but also of selecting prestored hypotheses, like in the case of diagnostic reasoning. However, as an internal inferential process, theoretical abduction does not capture many reasoning situations in which action plays a fundamental role. To account for those cases of ’thinking through doing’ in which action takes an epistemic role we propose to adopt the concept of manipulative abduc-tion. Diagnostic reasoning represents a suitable example of reasoning in which manipulative ’selective’ abduction plays a central role next to theoretical abduction. To illustrate the epistemic role of actions and the distribution of the cognitive and epistemic effort we can observe in some diagnostic tasks, the paper considers the case of medical semeiology and the use of external medical tools.

 
  file Magnani & Gatti (2003)_Embodied and Distributed Aspects of Abductive Diagnostic Reasoning.pdf
  commenti> 2003 Embodied and Distributed Aspects of Abductive Diagnostic Reasoning (Alberto Gatti) [paper]
< torna alla lista+ aggiungi commento# mostra tutto in formato stampabile

cogsci_unisi @ 2014